Sunday, December 11, 2011

That Is One Big Pair Of Scissors

Over at Top Horror Movies Club, I talked a little about how by watching movies from outside my own country, I learn about their local legends and lore. The movie that at last completed a review for was Trollhunter. That film was from Norway and I learned about their local lore about trolls of course. My review for here today was also about a local legend, but this time it is from Japan. This is something I find fun in foreign films as it mixes things up some. Doesn't always mean it is a good movie, but at least I learned a little something by watching it. In A Slit-Mouthed Woman (2007), or Carved: The Slit-Mouthed Woman, I learned about...well, the slit-mouthed woman.

Rumors are spreading pretty quickly with the children about the slit-mouthed woman. As the story goes, she will appear a child and ask if them if she is pretty. How to respond seems to vary though. As stories seem to grow, an earthquake happens, which seems to release something in one house. Soon after, children start to disappear. According to reports about these children, a woman that matches what the slit-mouthed woman looks like is reported at each scene. Once child, Mika (Rie Kuwana) is being abused by her mother when one of her teachers, Yamashita (Eriko Satô), tries talking to her about it, but it doesn't go well. Mika runs off, straight into the slit-mouthed woman (Mizuno Miki), who then takes off with Mika. Yamashita then teams up with Matsuzaki (Haruhiko Katô) who believes he knows who the slit-mouthed woman actually is. Will they be able to save the children, or is it too late for them?

The lore behind A Slit-Mouthed Woman actually goes back a long ways in Japanese history. Director/co-writer Kôji Shiraishi seems to drop the ball with this, and many other things. With a legend that goes back a long ways, I think I would have found a way to use that in my film. Shiraishi hints with a set of parents that it goes back a ways. The parents tell their kids that they talked about this woman even when they were in school. While it isn't said, it gave the impression that it goes back a long ways. Either way, this isn't the case at all. The woman in question becomes the legend only 30 years prior, which makes it a more recent legend. The plot itself has a lot to do with child abuse. In a way I support this. Just because it is a horror film doesn't mean the publicity it gets should be bad. Anything that gets a subject like child abuse into your mind is a good thing, as long as your not the abuser that is. That being said, I did think that A Slit-Mouthed Woman took it too far. Every major character in the film has been abused, is being abused, or is the abuser. It just felt like over kill.

Speaking of the abuse, some of it is shown in the film. The main person doing this was the slit-mouthed woman. There was a lot of things wrong that was around her character. When she appears, everyone seems completely helpless. There was plenty of times someone could have gotten away easy, or at least fought back, but they never really do. A hit or a kick, especially by the actress playing the slit-mouthed woman, didn't look hard at all, but the other actor would make it look like it was. She would barely move her foot and the person she "kicked" would act like a bone was broken. Okay, maybe it wasn't that bad, but you get the point.

A Slit-Mouthed Woman does manage to get gory here and there. With showing how the slit-mouthed woman got her name, to chopping off a head, the effects are pretty good. It was real gory, but it was a little more gory than I was expecting. The acting was just okay. I didn't really care for any one actor, but each did okay with their role. Outside of the lame hits and kicks anyway.

One of the cool things about this movie was that did go as far as killing off a kid. If you have read my reviews for very long, you know a movie gets major points for doing that. For A Slit-Mouthed Woman though, it was just too bad the rest of the movie didn't work. Another smaller problem with the plot is that we discover that the slit-mouthed woman takes over some other woman's body in order to do her work. So this made me wonder why there wasn't any women being reported as missing as well. A Slit-Mouthed Woman could have been a pretty good film, but it wasn't. To my surprise it still has a fairly good rating on both Netflix and IMDb. Neither has it listed as a great film, but I didn't find it to be an average film. To each their own I guess.
2 out of 5 Going after abused kids seems backwards to me

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

A couple things:
Of course, I haven't seen this film. Although, curiously, I don't own it on DVD, either.
ANYWAY...
Heather! Your comment in the rating seems to make sense on one level: if this slit-faced women/apparition/whatever seems bent on focusing on those people involved with abuse, why attack the victims?
Although, I also found it odd that in real life, abuse children often grow up to be abusers themselves. This fact also seemed contradictory. If the abused kid hated being abused, wouldn't they go out of their way to be kinder to their own children?
And perhaps a portion of abused kids do consciously behave with that motivation in mind.
But I guess the stronger impression on children is they grow up learning what they're exposed to.
the same with children of alcoholics. There's a higher chance that children growing in a household with alcohol abuse will themselves have drinking problems.
But, I know of some cases where the drinking in the family casues the kid to totally shun alcohol.
So, maybe that's what also happens. Maybe abused kids that don't grow up to be abusers, simply don't want to raise kids for fear of being like their parent(s). So, they don't become better parents, they just don't have kids, period.
But, this may be too much thinking for a scary film.
Or not.
Perhaps it might've been interesting if it turned out that the woman was an abused child, but she always felt responsible for her parent's actions.
So, in her screwed up sense of guilt (but it makes sense if you're a kid, 'I must be bad all the time if I'm always being punished") so perhaps she's placing blame on other victims as well. Perhaps her motivations are some combination of guilt and rage.
So, maybe this creature needs a combination exorcist/therapist to help her work through her issues.
Okay, that sounds funny, but I'm being serious.
I mean, isn't the Ghost Whisperer really just a paranormal therapist, in a way? And when she finally cures her ectoplasmic patient, the patient moves on...

The other thing I thought of was director Takashi Miike's ICHI THE KILLER. The main character has a slit open mouth as well, although he sort of fastens it "closed" and opens it for only special occasions...
I thought that was just creepy, and it is. But, I think it's interesting if there actually is a precedent in the Japanese culture for such a disfigurement.

BTW, I like this focus on foreign horror! Yay!

-Cattleworks

Heather Santrous said...

Well I did leave a part out. She abused her own kids when alive, so in a way it does make sense that she would do so even in death with other childern I suppose. Even so, it just seems backwards to me even knowing that.

Anonymous said...

Oh.
Hmmm...