When I was at a used book store a while back, I came across a book called The Ruins by Scott Smith. I picked it up right away to see if this was the same book that the movie was based on. It didn't take long before I realized that it was. Even though I loved the movie, I didn't know that it was based on a book by the same title. If I did know that, I had forgotten about it since then. I was curious to see what changes there were between book and movie, and to see if the book was better than the movie.
The book and movie follow the same plot. Friends Jeff and Eric, along with their girlfriends Amy and Stacy, are on vacation in Mexico. They become friends with Mathis, who is German but speaks English fairly well. They also get to know three guys who are Greek, but they can only speak Greek. Mathis becomes worried about his brother, who ran off with a woman to an archaeological dig. Even though he should hopefully return by the end of the week, Mathis still wants to go to the dig site to confront his brother. He turns to Jeff, who agrees to go with him. Since Jeff is going, that means everyone else is going as well. They get Pablo (one of the Greeks) to go, they know this isn't his real name but it is what he wants to be called. Pablo leaves a note to his brothers and joins the rest of the group. They have some trouble finding the dig site, but once they do they are surprised at how nice it looks with the flowering vines on the hill. Before they can do anything though, a Mayan from the nearby village tries to get them to leave. When Amy steps into the vines though, the group's fate is sealed.
If you haven't watched the movie yet, you really should. I have yet to watch the uncut version, even though I have it. One day I will. The screen play for the movie was written by Scott Smith, which makes since once you read the book. I was very surprised at how closely the movie followed the book. Sure there are some minor changes, like Pablo is gone completely from the movie version, but the book and movie follow each other for a good long while. Some of the events are different in the movie since Pablo is gone, which just means it happens to someone else. Book and movie eventually become different off from one another though. One thing I noticed right away was that we learn a lot more about each other characters. With the exception of the Greeks and even Mathis that is. To my surprise the bulk of the book covers a three day period. I liked that we got into the characters more over those days. One of my favorite parts of the book is when Amy, Stacy and Eric are trying to act as normal as possible even though they know they are in a lot of trouble. I know it seems odd I would pick something like that as my favorite part, but I could see myself doing that. Trying to act normal or try being silly for a little while to forget what was going on around me. The way the vines use this against them later was also very interesting.
From what I remember of the movie, Scott Smith not only changed how the last act plays out, but also the things that the vine does. It becomes apparent that the vines like to play with its food. I remember the vine being able to make noises in the movie, but in the book it can do even more than that. I know the idea of vines being the "bad guy" seems silly to a lot of people, but it does work very well. I think The Ruins threw off a lot of people because this was a completely different book than Smith's first novel. I'm sure people were expecting more of the same, but got a horror novel instead. Either way, The Ruins seems like a book you will either love, or hate completely.
One thing I didn't really care for is that the group, Jeff mainly, was already thinking about how to survive for a long period of time even on the first day there. I know things looked bad for them, even though they had no idea just how bad yet, but it still seemed silly that they were already thinking about peeing into the same bottle to get water from it later. Despite this I still enjoyed the book a lot. I got through it a lot quicker than I was expecting to do so. Even when I was reading it I was still trying to figure what I would do if I was in their shoes. The characters in the book may not have been the best around, but they felt very real to me, like people I would know. Not a perfect book, but if you liked the movie, I see no reason why you also wouldn't like the book.
4 out of 5 Would you be able to cut a vine out of your body?
5 days ago











