
The film I watched today is a borderline film when it comes to horror. It isn't a horror film actually, but it does have elements of horror in it. In fact,
Philosophy Of A Knife (2008) comes close to being a historical documentary. I ran across this film by accident. While looking at external reviews for a different film on IMDb, one of the links sent me to a page of reviews that didn't have the movie I was looking for. The poster to the left caught my eye so I checked it out. At the time,
Philosophy Of A Knife had yet to be released to DVD, so I am assuming the review was of an advanced copy. It sounded interesting to me. Then when I read that the film claims to be "one of the most violent, brutal and harrowing movies ever made," I knew I had to watch it. If for no other reason than to prove it wrong.
Philosophy Of A Knife tells us the story of Unit 731. Unit 731 is the Biological and Chemical Warfare Research and Development Unit of the Imperial Japanese Army. Phew, long name there. The film starts with a bit of a history lesson. The lesson starts right around the time of the Russia/Japan war of 1904-1905. It explores the mind set of Japan after these events, and how Unit 731 came about. From there, the film switches to more of a movie instead of a documentary. We meet a female nurse (played by, I believe, Yukari Fujimoto, voiced by Manoush), and an officer (Tetsuro Sakagami) of Unit 731. We follow them around and watch what they have to do, or observe what they see, in dealing with the prisoners. Sometimes we hear what they are thinking. They sometimes feel sorry for the people that are being experimented on, but also truly believe it is for the greater good. The officer has a bit of a thing for one of the women that is being held, so we hear about his conflicting feelings about that. We follow them through the course of the Unit, up until it is closed down at the end of the war in 1945. Now and then we are treated to an interview of Anatoly Protasov. Anatoly was a Russian doctor that was present at the war crimes trial after the war. He talks about Unit 731, the experiments preformed there, and also about what happened after the war.
The effects are very graphic at times. They really don't hold much back when it comes to the effects. That being said, the affect the graphic effects have is often lessened by the fact that they look so fake at times.
Philosophy Of A Knife was filmed almost completely in black and white. At times, I thought the the effects look kind of fake because they were in black and white. I thought maybe the effect wasn't coming across well, because there was no real color to it. At other times, I thought that even color wouldn't help the effect. Part of the problem is they linger on the effects for way too long. I will talk about that some more later though. Not all effects were bad, but lets say there are more bad than good. I can't say a lot about the acting because, outside of Anatoly Protasov, we never see anyone actually talking. We hear the nurse and officer talking, but that is a voice over that is telling us what they are thinking, not saying. The person doing the historical voice over seemed a little bored at one point. I thought that was funny actually. The acting is the actors trying to react to what is supposed to be happening to them. At times this doesn't work too well. They do look like they are in pain but, to me anyway, I would have been reacting to things a lot more if it was actually happening.
Now that I have most of that out of the way, I have to say that it took me forever to watch this film. Not because of the film itself, but because on how freaking long it is! It clocks in at just under four and a half hours. The good news is that it is divided into two parts. Three, if you include the introduction. The first part, of the actual movie, is just a tad over two hours. It took me a while to get through it because I had to leave about an hour into it, and then I kept pausing it to do other random things through the rest of the film. As I said before, the film is mostly in black and white. It is given a grainy look to match up with the historical footage that is used beside it. The only time it is in color is for the interview.
If you think that four plus hours is a long time, it is. It wasn't so much the time that made it long. If a movie really can get me into it, I don't notice how long it is. I loved the historical parts of the film. I found them to be interesting, even if the voice over was a little hard to hear at times. The film makers tell us in the introduction that what they filmed was not entirely based on fact. They want to leave the facts to the historians and scientists. What they filmed is the director's artistic vision of the facts that are known about Unit 731. I will let you decide what that actually means. To me, it meant a shit load of close ups. If there is anything, and I do mean anything, that could be filmed for a close up, director Andrey Iskanov found it. I'm not talking about the actor's face either. I mean just their eyes, or just their mouth, things like that. It isn't just the actors either, just about everything felt like it had a close up at some time or another. Because of this, it could make it hard to figure out what it was we were supposed to be seeing.
Speaking of what we are seeing, some scenes in
Philosophy Of A Knife linger way too long. Nothing like watching someone chop up body parts for a good ten minutes, let me tell you. Sadly, there are a lot of scenes that seem to go on for too long. It isn't just the torture scenes that go on too long either. We get to watch people walk through the snow for a long time. How exciting is that? There are endless shots of snow blowing through trees as well. The torture scenes were interesting to me. Not because of the torture itself, but because of knowing what humans are willing to inflict onto fellow humans. They tested how much pain a person could endure before passing out. What affects syphilis, poison, radioactivity, frostbite, and decompression do to the human body. Put an insect into a woman, and then later pulled the skin off her head to find it. Only once was it suggested they gave something for the pain, and that was for a pregnant woman.
Philosophy Of A Knife comes close to being pornographic at times. There is a sex scene, which isn't graphic really. But there is no shortage of both male and female nudity. The insect scene was probably more graphic, not only in the nudity, but also because of where they put the insect. While I know it wasn't real, it was still shocking to me. I guess that was another problem for me. Reading about what was done to people was one thing, it is shocking enough just to read about or even hint at it. Did we really have to see it, and for so long, though? One person, who happened to like the film, defends this. Saying it was important that we see it with out own eyes so we truly know how horrible it was. We are less likely to forget it, if we see it instead of reading about it. Maybe that is true, but I still had to wonder.
If you like historical type films, you might consider watching this, if you can stand it for four plus hours. I have not watched the extras yet, just because after four hours I was done watching for a while. Believe it or not, there are some deleted scenes. After watching the film, and reading what the extras are, I admit I was shocked there would be deleted scenes. When you let scenes drag on for ten minutes or longer, what could possibly be left on the cutting room floor? Anyway, the actual history part of the film was really interesting to me. I think the rest of the film would have been as well, if they had just trimmed it down.
2 out of 5 At least it wasn't six hours long