Monday, May 08, 2006

Ratings system

I probably should have covered this a long time ago, but as they say "better late than never". I don't know who "they" are, but "they" are around a lot. Before I take off for a nice swim, I thought I would explain how I go about rating the movies I watch. I decided right off that I would use a 5 star system, instead of a 10 star system. With a 10 star system I might give you, the reader, a better idea of how much or how little I liked a movie, but I like to keep things as simple as I can. I hope you all agree that a 5 star system is easy to understand. But just in case, here is what I think each star means:

1 star = hated it.
2 stars = didn't care for it, but didn't outright hate it. Mostly I felt the movie  came close to being good, but just missed.
3 stars = my somewhere in the middle type movie. I didn't love it but didn't hate it either. Usually most of the movie I felt was good, but there were enough things I couldn't really overlook.
4 stars = loved it.
5 stars = I really loved it. More on this one a little later.

I know you have noticed that I don't simply say stars after each rating. I say something else too. Sometimes it's silly but it always has to do with the movie in some way. I thought this was better than just saying stars all the time, and it makes me really think about what to say sometimes. It is more creative in other words.

I don't have any rules as far as the ratings go. There is nothing like this does or doesn't have to happen before I will give it a certain rating. There is one exception to that rule, and that is the 5 star rating. For that rating, I have to love the movie AND it needs to scare me. These are horror movies after all, so they should be scary in some way. There have been some 4 star movies that I was real tempted to give 5 stars to, but I stuck to my rule and didn't do that because they weren't scary. Maybe it would have been to someone else. I really feel the more horror movies a person watches, the harder it gets to scare that person. Plus some things scare you more than it would me and so on. So far I have only given 4 movies a perfect score. I'm not saying that the movie was perfect. I have yet to watch one of those, but it was close enough.

Now back to what I was saying, about certain things happening. I don't have a checklist sitting beside me while watching a horror movie. I go simply by how I feel after watching it. Were there enough good things that I liked to make it one I enjoyed, or enough bad things to drag it down. I know that just because I loved or hated a movie doesn't mean you, the reader, will get the same feelings from the movie. I am trying to give an honest review from a horror movie fan. I know not all my reviews are great, and I'm sure some of them haven't been all that good. But I try to be honest.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

I give my mouse 5 extra big hugs out of <5> possible, with an option to get even more later.

Jed Cooper said...

Howdy maam, just wanted to say I prefer your current rating system. Using 10 stars I think would overly complicate things. Like you when I watch a movie I am mostly concerned with how it affects me...did it scare me or at least get my attention.

I agree totally that the more horror movies you watch, the harder it becomes for one to really scare you. Lol, get a few more years and flicks under your belt Miss Heather and you will understand that part even more clearly than you do now. It has been a long time since one scared me. That is why a shiver or two from a movie now really gets my attention, because that is about the best I can hope for now, lol.

And please keep adding your comments to the stars..a great touch, that also highlights your sense of humor too (grinning). Like I have said several times already, your approach to the review is balanced with both the positive and negative aspects you felt. Listing both gives the reader a better understanding of what makes you tick when you watch a movie...the types of things that you enjoyed or would have enjoyed had they been included in the movie, and those things that detract for you. So the reader comes to have a better understanding of your rating system from your review as well. To me when you balance the positive with the negatives it just makes you much more credible.

You really are giving me a major hand in adding movies to my watch and ignore lists. So thank you for your efforts sweet lady (tips my hat).

jervaise brooke hamster said...

Heather, i know you`re quite happy
with your ratings system but what
do you think of mine:

10= unmittigated genius beyond all
imagining, only a few films in
history would be worthy of this
rating.
9= quite simply a masterwork.
8= better than great but still
not quite good enough to be
a masterpiece.
7= great, superb, marvellous, etc.
6= better than good but still not
quite good enough to be great.
5= a good solid entertaining film.
4= almost a good film but not
quite.
3= mediocre.
2= slightly better than rubbish
but not quite mediocre.
1= total garbage and hogwash but
not completely unwatchable.
0= a totally unwatchable
abomination with no redeeming
qualitys what-so-ever.

half-ratings are also available
for those really difficult to rate
movies, giving 20 possible
ratings.

well, what do you think
Heather ?.